Is it better to be poor in a land of poor, or poor in the land of plenty?
No one will believe us here when we tell them there are poor in America. They laugh. We have to tell them several times with serious expressions on our faces before they start to suspect we are serious. Then they ask if everyone has a flush toilet, and we say, “Well, just about everyone,” and they laugh and laugh and say, “Don’t be ridiculous! How do you say that everyone is not rich when everyone has a flush toilet?!”
And then what? How do we respond? How to explain to these people who make… what? a dollar a day? less? How do I explain to them that we are not rich? Of course we are. In Uganda we are the richest of the rich. But then we try to explain to them how expensive it is in America. We try to explain how we are students and how the money we have is from the bank. We try to explain debt. It’s no use.
We see the struggle of these people, to be sure, but we also see the joy. We see the way that everyone greets everyone when they pass, “Good morning. Hello. How are you?” We see a kind of community that has been rare in our country since… since when? World War II? Since the television began the process of isolating and dividing families from one another and from themselves? Since what were once porches of chatting families and neighbors became silent living rooms emanating blue light onto the sidewalks of America? Perhaps I romanticize…
They tell us that their idea is that everything is great in America and that everyone is welcomed with open arms, that jobs are easily found and that everyone is wealthy. And then they see us here, buying gifts for people at home, not arguing too much with the market vendors because we realize that we are fighting for twenty-five cents. So of course we are rich and everything is better in New York… But then they screw their faces when we try to tell them that we don’t know the names of our neighbors, and that the man next door looks at the floor and grunts when we’ve tried to greet him – for three years! They can’t comprehend it. Our neighbor has not once in three years said hello to us. His great stab at communication was scotch taping the front page of the Post, “BUSH WINS!” on his door in 2004. A man tells us that it would be a great dishonor if he failed to greet his neighbor each morning: “The first thing I do is greet my neighbors. Otherwise, how can we remain at peace?” Good question. Our solution, it seems, is good fences…
We are struggling with giving. Everyone we meet asks us to help them. Children ask for money. Teenagers explain that they would like to finish school and can we help them? The chief nurse at the hospital looked Aimee in the face yesterday and said, “Can you please take me to America with you?” Each time we strike up a conversation with a bodha driver, the ride ends with a payment by us and a request by him that we help... somehow. They seem ashamed to ask for help. They stare at the ground as they explain that their father or mother or brothers and sisters were killed by the rebels and they have no money for school fees. “Can you please help me?” It is utterly heartbreaking. What to do? The price to send one child to a year of private primary school is 200,000 shillings – just over 100 dollars. For private secondary school, it is between 400,000 and 500,000 – between $250 & $300. To send someone to the top University is about $1600 per year. And the NGO we are with, IC, is supporting children to go to school. To date, they are supporting nearly 500 children. But there are so many who apply. How can we support more? (just now, I stopped writing because Aimee’s bodha driver arrived to take her to the hospital for work. She was still getting ready so I went out to greet him. We said hello and then stood for a moment. I was taking in the morning. A beautiful, cool day; the sun was just beginning to warm the red soil and the tops of the huts across from where we live. After a moment of silence, he said to me, “Yes, I want to return to school. Can you help me? Last year my mother and father were killed. I am trying to save money with this work – indicating his moped – but it is difficult to raise school fees”).
On Christmas night we ate a restaurant in town. All thirteen of the muzungus were there (it was the night of the first great spiritual/philosophical debates). We were laughing and arguing and drinking beer. A young man in a beautiful red and black African shirt came over to ask if he could take a photo with us. With him were his two brothers, his wife and his two-month old infant. We stood and snapped a photo with him. Then Aimee and I, happy and open, went over to their table to hold the baby, ask about them and their lives. We chatted for a while and snapped some more photos. Then we were invited to lunch the next day. “Please call.” I promised I would. Then he said, with a shy smile, “Don’t disappoint me. Please.” I said I would not and that we would call the next day. The next day I planned to call at the appointed time. But we awoke early and we decided to do some washing for the first time since we’d arrived. To make the story short, I washed my jeans that held the scrap of paper upon which I had written Kenny’s phone number. I had lost the number. The paper was completely white except for the name, “Kenny”. I was horrified. It was like a movie. I imagined the brothers waiting by the phone, expecting my call, thinking I was a liar. I had disappointed them after all.
We decided to take a bodha to the restaurant where we had met them; perhaps someone knew them from town. And luckily, it worked. One of the managers was an “OB”. (If you went to school with someone as a child, or grew up in the same village, and then parted ways for school or relocation or whatever, this person, upon meeting them again, was an OB – “Old Boy”. You could also have an OG – “Old Girl”.) So he drew us a map and called another bodha and we were taken to the village home. They were overjoyed and told us that, yes, in fact they had been waiting by the phone fearing that we had “deceived” them. We spent a wonderful afternoon with them. They had invited all of their relatives to the house to meet us. Apparently it was a very big honor for them to have us at their house. The family is well off compared to most we have met. They struggle, but they are able to send one child, Tonny, to university in Kampala. Kenny’s wife, Teddy, works for an HIV/AIDS organization and is able to put herself through the local university. She raises her two children and works during the week and then attends classes all day on the weekends. Through her, Aimee made her connection with Sister Florence, a head maternity nurse at the hospital. The father has begun building what he hopes will be a small hostel for local university students as a way to generate income. He was once a municipal engineer but he is now retired and his retirement package is used up. The hostel – as well as the rest of the house – stands only partially built. Piles of sand and bricks, warped planks of wood, and half constructed cement walls litter the property. The father has dreams of building a private primary school on some property he owns but again, there is no money. He asks if we can help. We say that we, personally, can’t. He asks if we would be willing to talk some more about his ideas. We say of course. What’s the harm in talking…?
Now, days later, the relationship has become somewhat overwhelming. They do not ask for anything, but they want to spend time with us everyday. The young men, Kenny and Tonny, are 26 and 24. Tonny is on holiday from school. Kenny cannot find work. Their days are free and they don’t understand that we do not have hours and hours each day to come to lunch, to spend time. The work we have come to do is beginning and our days are full. The culture here doesn’t understand “grabbing a cup of coffee” for a half hour before parting ways to do one’s own thing. When we’ve agreed to see each other, we have been together for five or six hours. Last night, Kenny called my phone eight times in a row. I had already seen them that morning, to bring Teddy some herbal tea that Aimee recommended for some lactation issues she was having. Instead of dropping off the tea and departing, I was implored to stay. Knowing I was coming they ran out and bought food especially for me. They told me that to leave would be a dishonor for them. I ate. Instead of getting to work on some NYU stuff I had been putting off, my afternoon was swallowed with this obligatory meal. Then the phone rings eight times in the evening and I am trying to avoid it. Finally I answer and he tells me that he has come to town with a traditional dish for us. He has carried it all the way from the village. I leave the compound in frustration, now angry at their generosity. Or, more precisely, angry at the complexity of relationships here. How to explain “down time”?
We are told by IC not to give away money on the street, not to give food away to the workers here. Even this was difficult for us, but we understand. We cannot solve all of the problems. While the intention is from the heart, giving handouts only breeds resentment when the next muzungu refuses to give. We will perpetuate the idea that we are all rich; then, if we don’t give, we will be seen as harsh and uncaring… And the truth is, these people have survived for centuries without Westerners here, and they will survive for many more centuries, with or without Westerners here. But how to not give from the heart? How to contain Love? Aimee and I opened our hearts, which brought us into this wonderful opportunity to know, to become friends with, and to experience the quotidian routines of an African family. And we are grateful to know them. But if we are honest with our love, we see that we must also be honest with our limits. When Kenny said that they had bought food for the new year and that they hope we will arrive on the 1st of January at 9 am and stay until 6 pm… well now, how does one explain that we are actually planning to celebrate with the other Americans that night and that, well, American New Year’s Eve parties could end at nine in the morning?!?!?
The last thing we ever want to do is disappoint anyone. Yet, we see that we need to risk disappointing for the sake of honesty. We cannot be saviors. We are not saviors.
It seems clear that so many see the Westerners as a potential way out their plight. As pleasant and kind as everyone has been, we have to remember that this year – the spring of 2006 – the rebels were still terrorizing the villages. This is a war-zone, still. This is the South after the American Civil War. People are walking around traumatized, heartbroken and angry. And many, many people are hoping to find a muzungu who will help them. As Kenny said to me on the second day, “I have wanted to have an American friend for so long, and now I finally do.” What does that mean? Why would he want an “American” friend? Because we are so innately good? Or is it, partly, as one NGO volunteer said, “…because they are looking for tickets out of hell.”
Speaking of hells, I have been visiting the prison here for the past few days, talking to the chief officers and also the head of the prison ministry program. His name is Walter. The more I spoke to him, the clearer it was that “prison theatre” wasn’t happening. It was all about preaching the gospel and hoping that by getting the inmates to “accept Jesus Christ into their hearts,” they would abstain from committing further crimes upon their release. I asked if there were services for different religions. He said, “Of course. At 8:30 am there are services for the Catholics. At 10:30, we have services for the Protestants, and at 4:30 there are services for the Pentecostals.” So much for religious diversity.
It is not my intention to continue harping on religion, but it is so much of our experience here, so much of what I am reading about, as well as so much of the experience of the African continent, that I feel compelled to write about it. The conversations with the Christian students at the IC house are both fascinating and exhaustingly mind numbing. We sit and eat, passing salt, pepper and Top-Up brand Ketchup, and having intense religious debates. I really like everyone we are living with. We both do. We laugh together a lot, and it has been wonderful to learn about their lives and aspirations. They are young, enthusiastic, and deeply desirous to find ways to give service, but I can only go with them, philosophically, to a point. I see the love of Jesus as it has been presented to us through history. I can see and deeply appreciate the message of love and service and loving one’s neighbor as oneself. I think that the message of turning the other cheek was a radical departure from the Western and Near/Middle-Eastern traditions and customs that had come before. But I can also see those same virtues in Gandhi, in Rabbi Hillel, in Gautama Buddha, in Ramana Maharshi. Shall we dismiss Gandhi because he does not call Jesus “God’s only son”? I can’t get into it. And the fact is, there is actually little room for discussions because after a time, it becomes clear that our paradigms are completely different. I am not going to be convinced that the Bible is literal, and that every word is a direct transmission from God; they won’t buy my point that it is poetry and metaphor, pointing to that which is too enormous for humans to contain in language. They will never convince me that Jesus is the “only” way to God. I will never convince them that, as Jiddu Krishnamurti says, “the path to Truth is pathless,” and that, as far as I can see, you can call yourself whatever you want – what counts is the way you treat the other creatures of the Earth. At some point, the discussion just has to end. Going around in circles for too long makes me a bit queasy. I will believe what I believe, and they will believe I’m doomed to Hell. Pass the salt, please…
But back to prison: So I’m talking to Walter and he’s telling me about the Gospel preaching. I like him. He is a big man with a wide, stained smile and a laugh that is discordantly high and giggly. When he makes a joke, he giggles and his whole big belly shakes and shakes. Then he holds out his hand and I grab it and we hold each other’s hands, laughing together. Walter finally asks what I do in the States and I tell him about my work in prison. Suddenly he says, “Oh yes! We also do drama here!” I am shocked. Maybe he’s misunderstood. Drama? Oh yes. In fact, they’ve just done a play about HIV/AIDS. I tell him that the last prison play I was involved in was an educational piece about HIV and Hepatitis C. I ask if I can observe and he says, in typical understated Acholi-speak, “It is OK.”
Next day: Walter passes me on his moped in the street and waves at me. I don’t recognize him, but think he is a bodha driver offering a ride. I dismiss him, “No thank you.” He says something and I look back to realize that it’s Walter. I tell him I thought he was a bodha bodha and he shakes and giggles and extends his fleshy hand. He tells me to come to the prison at 3pm to meet the “big boss”. I do so but Walter is at lunch and the big boss is not around. I return at 4pm. I sit and talk to Walter. He asks me what I think of the Gospels. I tell him I’m not so much of a preacher. He laughs and tells me that he likes what I am doing with the drama work and he wants me to come and work for him in Gulu. “To do ministry.” I tell him I’m not much of a missionary; I am more of a teacher. He says that he is a preacher and a teacher, “But I have no talent for drama.” I tell him that drama is my talent. He says, “So you do not have to do the Gospels to do ministry. Your drama is your ministry.” I agree with him. “I can see becoming the director of the prison drama in all of East Africa!” I laugh but he is persistent. “Why not? You love Gulu. You can do your drama work in the North here. We have twenty prisons. Then you can begin to spread out. We will bring you to Kenya and Tanzania also.” Then the kicker: “You will do some dramas about Jesus and the Gospels…”
In the words of my in-laws, oy vey!
The prisoners are performing a drama on New Year’s Day at 2pm. Aimee and I are invited. We don’t know the theme, but I have a sneaking suspicion. There is an entry fee for me, the muzungu: two boxes of mukwano, a crumbly blue soap. Apparently they have no soap for the prisoners. No extra blankets, either, and prison uniforms come from the district office when they come. The young men I’ve seen are either wearing the yellow uniform – short sleeves and loose shorts, with flip-flops, or they are barefoot and shirtless wearing whatever pants they had on when they were arrested.
Ugh. I guess that’s all for now. There is so much more. I haven’t even mentioned the days we’ve spent at H.E.A.L.S. (I can’t remember what the acronym stands for), an NGO that serves young children using art and play as therapy. It was started by a local woman named Joely. I have begun working with a few of the children developing short dramas based on their experiences during the war. They will perform their work next week. Aimee has bonded very closely with some of the young girls at H.E.A.L.S., especially an AIDS orphan named Nancy. We suspect she has AIDS, too, and it is very sweet and melancholy to spend time with her. She and the other girls have been teaching Aimee the local Acholi songs and they have given her an Acholi name, Lakisa. It means something like, “merciful from God”.
Aimee has so much exciting news to report but I will leave it to her. She started in the hospital maternity ward yesterday and she is there again today. Her shift is from 9am until 3pm. She looks like a real nurse – scrubs, white sneakers, hair pulled back in neat braids. The nurses at the hospital are so pleased with her professionalism and appearance. They have really taken to her and have taken her under their wings. She is learning a lot! But as I say, I will leave her story to her. It’s a doozy!
Happy New Year.
Until next time,
love and blessings to you all… and a special shout-out to Messr. Harvey Bruce Brill-Bott whom we miss terribly!
kevin
p.s. - famiglia! avete visto il foto?! gli italiani sono anche in Africa! venite qua, tutti! abracci e baci! vi manchiamo moltissimo! a prestissimo...